Holmes and Moriarty The new official Sherlock Holmes novel

A Duel of Minds — Reviewing Holmes and Moriarty

Corinne Nathalie am 14.05.2026
Bewertungsnummer: 3137713
Bewertet: Buch (Taschenbuch)

“Holmes and Moriarty” is a clever, high‑velocity mystery that grabs you from the first page and refuses to let you settle. Rubin Gareth structures the novel with real daring: half told through the razor‑edged perspective of Sebastian Moran, half through the steady, familiar voice of John Watson. The contrast between the two narrators gives the story a rhythm that feels electric—sharp, surprising, and constantly shifting under your feet. The language sparkles. Gareth has a gift for crisp, witty phrasing and for stitching humour into tension without ever breaking the mood. The pacing is relentless in the best way: scenes snap forward, twists land with confidence, and the plot keeps tightening until you realise you’ve read far more pages than you meant to. The dual‑lens structure is the book’s standout feature. Moran’s chapters are stylish and unpredictable, while Watson brings emotional grounding and a sense of classic detective‑fiction warmth. Together, they create a narrative that feels both fresh and rooted in tradition—a balance that’s surprisingly hard to pull off. Sherlock Holmes himself appears less frequently than one might expect or even whishes, but when he does step into the frame, the impact is unmistakable. His presence is felt even in his absence: in the tension between narrators, in the shadows of the plot, in the way every character seems to orbit the idea of him. It’s a bold choice, and while some readers may wish for more Holmes on the page, the restraint gives the novel its own identity. Overall, “Holmes and Moriarty” is a witty, fast‑paced, linguistically playful thriller with a genuinely intriguing twist of structure. It’s the kind of book you pick up for a quick chapter and suddenly realise you’ve devoured half of it. Fresh, clever, and full of momentum—a fantastic read.